My Husky loves these bones. I give them to her as a treat. She can hardly wait for me to open the package!My dog really likes these. The size is good for a 30 lb dog but not sure if they are helping with tartarDogs love them but they are very messy. Don't know if it's just my dogs but all three left residue of the treat where they ate them.dog likes them, however, she eats them so fast that I do not believe they do a good job of cleaning the teeth.My dog really liked them but got to liking them too much. She starting eating it so fast she was going choke.From the moment I opened the package, I was happy with this product. From the packaging to the ingredients to the way my dogs reacted to having these treats. Every step I am thrilled with. My only complaint is the pricing on them however I am someone that lives with a limited budget. $16 for a bag of 15 is a little steep however it is a lot cheaper than having to put another pet through dental surgery.When it comes to my dogs, they all loved them. Every time I grab the bag they all go crazy! I have 4 dogs of all different sizes and even my lab who is unbelievably picky with any food or treats we give him, was trying to take my other dog's treat. He also has stomach sensitivity issues and had no tummy issues whatsoever after consuming these treats. Seeing that made me a huge fan of this product and I would gladly recommend this to anyone needing a dental chew for a sensitive, picky pup, or any pup for that matter.Between the way my dogs reacted to me grabbing the bag, the way they devoured every last crumb of their treat, and the way all of my dogs' tummies handled the treats, I will definitely be purchasing more of these as I can. Well done.My pups had this chewed up in less than a minute. Left little hard pieces all overThey smell incredible, and my 19 lb dog loves them. However, he chews through a small one in just 1 minute, which is why I gave this product 3 stars. I'm not sure how much it's cleaning his teeth because of how quickly he goes through it. He's been using them for a week.The large size looks like it'll last much longer, so I may wind up giving him one Large a week instead. (They're a lot more calories).My dog didn't have bad breath before, just some plaque starting on his teeth. I think these would help with breath issues though. I'll update as we use them for longer.