I have two dogs who are a bit sensitive to changes in their diet. They loved these and begged for more! They had no tummy issues, and no skin or ear problems after eating these. There was no foul odor, in fact they smell quite nice! I appreciate ingredients that can be pronounced, as I’m quite “choosey” about what I feed my fur-babies. They were a bit soft, like a baked treat, and they seemed to like that texture. Not everything they eat needs to be crunchy! We will buy more for sure!