Little expensive but dog loves it and its great for hiding pillsMy puppy loves to eat his kibbles mixed with the delectables.Sorry but this stuff drips everywhere.My dog won’t use these because it comes out like water and then there’s a mess to clean. Even when I try to use it to let me dog lick, it gets on her nose and we have to clean her up. It gets on the carpet. It smells bad. I don’t recommend it. It’s way too watery and smelly.My cats are in love with theseMy shorkie loves ut.I think they are overpriced. But they work. Contrary to belief....I think pets get tired of eating the same dog food every day.My dog seems to really like.I used this as a topper on their hard food. They ate every bit of the hard food without a problem. Usually they won’t eat it without some soft food mixed in, but this dis the trick!!