My dogs love these treats! I wish there were more of them to each package!Had no problem with the dogs not wanting these.My dog loves these but they are expensive!Lasted 5 minutesMy dogs go nuts for this product I just wish the had bigger bags with more in them. I like this brand of treats cause they keep it simple and healthy. I will always buy from this brand.While I’m not crazy about the smell - but that’s true of most dog treats for me and I mean nothing against this product. My dog loves them. That’s all that mattersMy dogs love these and the beef flavor. Not long lasting but they still love them.I have a chorkie and a medium sized mixed breed, they both are in love with with the nudges treats!